Among the original-series characters who returned in Twin Peaks: The Return, one of the last
to appear was Audrey Horne, who wasn't seen onscreen until well into the second
half of the season. Despite this late reintroduction, Audrey's four scenes stood
out prominently in a number of ways, being strange, then increasingly strange,
and finally abruptly ending the season's second-to-last broadcast. The Audrey
scenes are hard to decipher in any sensible way and because of – not
"despite" – this, may be among the most important of the season.
First, I offer a quick overview of the four scenes with
Audrey. More details of these scenes and related ones will follow later:
Audrey's four scenes occur near or at the end of episodes
12, 13, 15, and 16. In each of them, she interacts with only one person: her
husband Charlie, who has never been seen before and does not appear in any
other scenes. In the first three, they are in what appears to be their home,
discussing whether or not to go to the Roadhouse to look for a man named Billy.
The conversations they have are remarkably bitter and hostile, frequently
nonsensical, and include the information that Audrey is having an affair with
Billy. They discuss other people, including Chuck and Tina, none of whom
clearly links to any characters we can otherwise identify. In their fourth
scene, Audrey and Charlie appear at the Roadhouse, where the M.C. introduces a
song from Season One as "Audrey's Dance." Audrey dances alone to it,
then a fight breaks out, and she suddenly seems to wake up disoriented in an
all-white room.
There are many oddities, as stated above, and we must almost
certainly conclude that the Roadhouse scene is a memory, dream, or delusion. However,
the first three Audrey scenes also contain remarkable inconsistencies that make
their reality suspect as well:
• Audrey and Charlie's conversation remains on a single
topic, going in circles, while multiple days pass for the other characters in
the show. Much is made of putting jackets on or not, and in the transitions
between them, jackets are suddenly on or off, while all of the other clothing
remains the same. It is hard to explain those scenes as taking place
consecutively or on different days.
• The dialogue is very strange in tone and emotion. Charlie
seems minimally hurt when Audrey makes exceptionally cruel comments. She seems
like a young girl speaking with false confidence about things like contracts as
though she is pretending to understand them. She is very aggressive in the
first and third scenes, but whimpers defensively in the second.
• The dialogue is frequently illogical on a factual
level. Charlie claims that they can't look for Billy because there is a New
Moon. This is not only irrelevant to looking for someone indoors, but
contradicted by a shot showing a crescent Moon. The third scene begins with
Audrey saying almost exactly what she said to begin the first scene. Audrey
says that they have already looked everywhere else for Billy, which certainly
can't be true (e.g., he could be in another state). Charlie protests that he is
too sleepy to look for Billy. Audrey sarcastically asks if Charlie has a
crystal ball, and he answers her literally, not understanding the sarcasm. (Remarkably, he says that he does not have a crystal ball, but there is a crystal ball right there on his desk.) Audrey
suddenly asks if "this" is Ghostwood. Charlie threatens to end
Audrey's story "too." Audrey asks what story that is if it's
"the story of the little girl who lives down the lane."
• Audrey's hair is quite different in the final "wake
up." If her hair looks like that now, the scenes with Charlie are probably
not happening close to the current time, if they ever happen(ed) at all.
• There are numerous references to someone being an
unreliable narrator. Audrey says that she has details about Billy from her
dream in which he is injured. Charlie suggests that Audrey is on
"drugs." Audrey says that she's seeing Charlie as though he's a
"different person" and doesn't feel like she is herself.
Suffice it to say, the first three scenes, no less than the
Roadhouse scene, are difficult to explain as a real interaction between two
married people, and we should suspect that all four of the scenes are unreal,
with the final "wake up" showing Audrey's actual situation, which
seems to be an institution.
We may also note that in several of Lynch's films since Twin Peaks last aired, main characters
dream or imagine their lives to be very different than they are, and the
viewers are shown extended scenes that are part of a delusional reality; the
viewer, like the characters, face the challenge of realizing what is real and
what was the delusion. This pattern holds true in Lost Highway, Mulholland
Drive, and Inland Empire. There
is also a prominent scene in which Gordon Cole says that in one of his dreams,
he is told by Monica Bellucci that their lives are like a dream, but, the
question is, who is the dreamer?
It is easy enough to adopt an interpretation, then, that
Audrey is institutionalized and her vision of a very unhappy marriage with
Charlie and a missing lover named Billy is just a delusion, and that the third
scene repeats dialogue from the first because she repeats different versions of
the delusion on multiple nights. We may also imagine that she has "Audrey's dance" in her dream because the original version of that scene, from 1990, was stirringly memorable, helping to give Sherilyn Fenn national fame and status as a sex symbol, and this is something that older Audrey may remember fondly as the best moment for her younger self. But then, the fantasy goes wrong and she wakes up. This explains the four scenes adequately.
However, that explanation doesn't go quite far enough.
Audrey's scenes can't be merely her internal delusion because other scenes
during the season echo things from the four scenes with Charlie. This is most
obvious concerning a scene in episode 14, in which young women named Megan and
Sophie discuss a group of people with names and biographical details matching
the people in Audrey and Charlie's scenes. To be specific, there is a Billy who
is bleeding profusely from the nose and mouth, and a Tina and another man who,
in Audrey and Charlie's telling, is named Chuck. The last detail provided is
when Sophie asks the name of Megan's mother, and Megan answers portentously
that her name is Tina, and both characters pause strangely in response to this.
It should be noted that this scene occurs in the approximate time slot of the
fourteenth episode that Charlie and Audrey's scenes occur in the two episodes
before and two episodes after, with the time slot as well as the character
names suggesting that this scene is part of the Audrey-verse. They also mention
a "nut house," which could match the appearance of Audrey's actual
location. So perhaps this fifth scene is also part of Audrey's delusion.
But this, too, doesn't go far enough. Episode 7 ends with a
man rushing into the RR Diner and asking for Billy. The music accompanying this
scene is the 1959 instrumental song, "Sleep Walk." Perhaps this, too,
is a hint that this scene, and all the Audrey scenes, are a dream.
We might, alternately, conclude that the Sophie-Megan scene
as well as the "Billy" scene are real and that Audrey, inside the
institution, has somehow gathered details of the real world because Megan is,
as Sophie suggests, spending time inside a "nut house" and could
spread gossip that Audrey hears.
And yet this still doesn't go far enough. There is a fight
in the Roadhouse involving a Chuck and this fight leads to Freddie punching
someone, and possibly inducing a bleeding nose and mouth. There is also a drunk
who is bleeding profusely from his nose and mouth in a jail cell, where he
mockingly repeats everything he hears. Moreover, both Audrey and The Arm in the
spirit world use the same curious phrase "Story of the little girl who
lives down the lane." The Arm says this in Episode 18, after Audrey has
said the phrase. Now we require one of several exceptional explanations:
• Audrey is dreaming as much as is needed to explain all of
the connections.
• Audrey is dreaming everything.
Maybe no part of this season "really" takes place and Audrey is
"the dreamer" of every moment of every episode. Note that the
bleeding man in the jail cell is present when Andy says that he needs to take
everyone upstairs, but is not present when they arrive upstairs. If that very
important scene is part of Audrey's dream, it's hard to draw a boundary around
her dream and everything else. And if she knows there's a Bad Cooper, then
maybe even the second and/or first season of Twin Peaks is a dream, too.
• There is a real world, a spirit world, as well as Audrey's
delusion, and something or someone is communicating between all of them.
• The similarities between Audrey's dream and the real world
exist but are simply unexplained. In the Twin Peaks reality, we've seen this
before. In particular, recall that when Leo was shot, there was also a similar
shooting on Invitation to Love. And
remember when inhabiting spirits MIKE and BOB's names mirrored high school Mike
and Bobby. Probably quite close to why the word "Twin" is in the title,
Twin Peaks shows things that align in
ways that almost make sense, but not quite.
• Maybe the Audrey scenes work on a metalevel. Note that
Charlie threatens to end Audrey's story ("too") and one episode
later, the series does indeed end Audrey's story! This isn't explainable as a
meaningful connection if she is having a delusion and then her life goes on as
before. It would mean that the Twin Peaks
show as a piece of fiction is an
object within the Audrey-verse. We may further wonder, then, if Charlie is a
stand-in for the creative forces on the show, perhaps for David Lynch himself.
This would be the first instance, then, of the show breaking the fourth wall
and making Audrey not the dreamer of part/all of the show, but as a fictional
character aware (even if deleriously so) of her fictional nature.
If the final possibility is indeed true, and the Audrey
scenes work on a metalevel, then there is added significance to the two uses of
the phrase, "story of the little girl who lives down the lane." This
opens the discussion wider to a consideration of what the phrase means in
Episode 18, and to what Episodes 17 and 18 mean overall… Here, I will
conclude the portion of the discussion that focuses on Audrey and take up the
topic again in another post. Suffice it to say, the scenes with Audrey seem
deeply significant, far more than those of other characters and may encompass
what the show's entire story in fact is.