In September 2006, Grant Morrison began a stint as writer of
the Batman title with issue #655. His
more-or-less unbroken tenure jumped from one title to another, ending seven
years later with Batman, Inc. (vol 2)
#13, after a total of 75 issues across four titles, plus a handful of scenes in
three other titles. Morrison portrayed three different heroes (and briefly, a
fourth) as Batman, not counting a number of villains and proteges who posed as
Batman or variants of Batman. In terms of the stature of the writer, the
character, and the number of issues, it's a run that has been matched rarely if
ever in DC's history. Now its beginning is a full decade in the past and its
ending went on sale three years ago.
According to Morrison, he originally pitched a run 15 issues
in length, and did not foresee that his tenure would end up five times that
length. The entire body of work breaks down into three major stories averaging
about two years each, augmented by a six-issue miniseries and then a few
special features here and there. Even the first of those three major stories,
though, ran past its planned length of 15 issues, to at least 23 by the most
conservative count, before it looped back to include four more issues of Batman in related Final Crisis crossovers and a gem of an anniversary issue in Batman #700 that was largely separate
plotwise from Morrison's other Batman work.
The stories making up the bulk of the run were:
• The Black Glove's attempt to destroy Batman, Batman #655-681.
• The battle between Batman (Dick Grayson) and El Penitente in Batman and Robin with the Joker
playing his own game against both sides.
• Bruce Wayne's odyssey through time in Return of Bruce Wayne, trying to escape
the doom planned for him by Darkseid.
• The effort by Levitathan to destroy Gotham and get final
revenge against Batman, as chronicled in Batman,Inc.
The three longest arcs have certain distinctive
characteristics that make them alike: Each lasted about twenty issues and told
the tale of one master criminal plot headed by a single master villain who was,
in each case, unknown to the reader until deep into the story. Those master
villains worked through intermediaries, who themselves made formidable foes in
their own right, challenging Batman – the various Batmen – to a
respectable degree before a final round in which Batman squared off against the
ultimate evil force in the story.
This mold was established in the first of those three, with
the Black Glove's master plan revealing its first subtle – and at the
time, inscrutable – clues in Morrison's very first issue, with Dr. Simon
Hurt being revealed only very gradually, as a pair of hands holding binoculars,
then a voice without a face, then as a figure in uncertain memories, never appearing
on-panel in the present with Batman until the final pages of the second-to-last
issue of Batman, R.I.P. The patience
with which Morrison developed his story and its signature villain is nearly
unmatched anywhere in the history of the medium of superhero comics. The
lingering mystery, "Who is the Black Glove?", propelled Morrison's
story to a high degree of notoriety, enthralling many fans while the plot's
ambiguity and psychedelic weirdness frustrated others.
That first long arc in Batman
also, eventually, turned out to follow themes that Morrison had shown in his
earlier works. His very first Batman story, published only in a British
publication as a text-only story, had Catwoman invade the Batcave. R.I.P. adapted the idea of a femme
fatale inside Batman's sanctuary by having lover/enemy Jezebel Jet strike at
Bruce Wayne inside the Batcave. Arkham
Asylum showed Batman entering the titular institution to face a pack of
enemies led by the Joker; this is what happened also in R.I.P. as the carefully-orchestrated "danse macabre" of
Doctor Hurt. And Gothic, Morrison's
classic four-parter from the early days of the Legends of the Dark Knight title, showed Batman in a supernatural
story involving an ageless man who'd made a deal with the Devil. R.I.P. dropped clue after clue that
Simon Hurt might be the universe's ultimate evil until Batman himself
considered the possibility, a reveal that confused many readers, prompting
Morrison to clarify that it was, indeed, "the story of how Batman cheats
the Devil."
One of the great contributions of Morrison's run was in
tying together so much of Batman's history, sending readers to the archives
through whatever means they had, to investigate the Black Glove mystery by
seeking clues in older – much older – stories. Morrison, like Steve
Englehart before him, wrote a new Batman story that referred to considerably
older ones, not from the past two or five years, but stories from decades
earlier. Astonishingly, Morrison used a nameless character who appeared in one
story in 1963 as the basis for his big, new villain. Using the freedom provided
by Infinite Crisis' soft reboot, he
made many minor changes to Batman's backstory, altering the 2005 status quo in
order to bring back many miniscule facets of Batman's history such as Professor
Nichols' time machine, Professor Milo's mind-altering gas weapons, and many
long-forgotten Batman wannabes. As 2008 went by, readers were poring through
the archives for the purpose of looking for Black Glove clues, but learning a
heck of a lot about Batman lore as they went.
The first of Morrison's three long story arcs was what was
originally planned as the entire run; when the next two came along, they copied
that first once closely. The second, with replacement Batman Dick Grayson as
the target of El Penitente, turned out to have the exact same villain, and many
parallels to R.I.P., though turning,
eventually, into a farce with Doctor Hurt slipping on a banana peel. The third,
with a mysterious Leviathan who attracted an army of followers in Gotham, began
according to a very similar script, though Talia was the villain this time, a
"bad mother" instead of the first two stories' metaphorical bad
fathers.
Given that the first run carried out Morrison's plan to
fruition, at nearly double the originally-anticipated length, how does one perceive
the rest of the run? As a corporation capitalizing on a business success by
soliciting more of the same product from the same source? As a creative mind
exploring fertile territory, going deeper and deeper? Both of these are true. While
the Batman and Robin and Batman, Inc. stories were far less
original in their architecture than the original run in Batman, they were finer in their craftsmanship. The Batman who
began Morrison's run as overly gruff and self-admiring to the point of parody
("Hh. You didn't know I had a rocket.") turned into a finely-tuned
and plausible optimum man by the work's end. The purple prose of the
"Clown at Midnight" text-only Joker issue, the bombast of the adult
Damian in issue #666, and the acknowledgement of Batman's silly past with the
Club of Heroes and appearances by Bat-Mite struck many readers as overreach on
Morrison's part; such judgments are subjective, but such fan criticism became
rarer during the second and third long arcs. The Batman and Robin work is particularly noteworthy for Morrison's use
of different pencillers, blending his scripts with each artist's visual style
in virtuoso fashion. By the time Batman,
Inc. began, Morrison was perceptibly more in command of his starring
character and his world, with an Argentine tango of death, the daring of
Batman's Matches Malone identity, flashbacks to Kathy Kane, and the passion of
Damian Wayne all having just the right effect. Perhaps the second two long
stories were refinements of the first, and perhaps one might imagine the three
long arcs merged into one idealized version combining all of the three arcs'
merits and none of their flaws, but we are richer for having the three, and to
see Morrison's Batman evolve from the brooding loner who throws the Joker into
a dumpster to the impassioned altruist who understands his destiny and is
compelled to return from a brief retirement to start his war on Gotham's
criminals anew.
Arguably the run's most prominent legacy will prove to be
the character who was introduced (earlier inspirations withstanding) at the end
of the first issue, Damian Wayne. It was a bold assertion by Morrison and his
editors to add Batman's son to the mythos, one that was done with hesitation.
Originally, Morrison planned for Damian's seeming death at the end of #658 to
be an actual death, but the character returned, only to die near the end of the
Batman, Inc. series, only to be
brought back yet again by other creators.
Other innovations from throughout the run have been erased
– at least for now – by DC's two
new fresh starts, which make Bruce Wayne's revenge on Joe Chill a memorable
scene that is no longer in continuity. The ambiguous clues suggesting that
Doctor Hurt ordered the murders of Thomas and Martha Wayne seemed to build to a
possible reveal that Morrison never got around to, and any possible intentions
to that effect are now irrelevant insofar as 2016's continuity is concerned. However,
the New 52 era of Batman, still largely in continuity, was led by Scott Snyder
incorporating many Morrisonian inspirations, including an evil organization of
wealthy Gothamites going far back into the past and led by central figures
possessing unnatural longevity. Snyder's Court of Owls is sufficiently like the
Black Glove to be perceived as an homage to Morrison's invention if not a
needless reinvention of it.
In the era of trade paperbacks collecting the monthly
titles, Morrison's run will be for sale indefinitely, and acquiring new readers
at some rate far into the future. It is unlikely, though, that any of them will
get the original experience had by readers who were picking up the new issues,
particularly the middle portion of the run in 2007–2010. At that time, the
monthlies had a tangled chronology – partly because Morrison's story involved
flashbacks, hidden reveals, and time travel, and partly because different
titles were simply giving us the story out of order. Sometimes this was jarring
and seemed like an uncontrolled accident, as when the other Batman titles had R.I.P. Crossover on their cover and
seemed to be telling stories set after Batman,
R.I.P.'s conclusion, but whose writers, in retrospect, probably didn't know
the ending of Morrison's story. In other cases, the big company-wide events
linked up with Morrison's story out of sequence, most notably when his own Final Crisis involved Batman but was
published concurrently with R.I.P. but
was set after it. Thus, we were shown Bruce Wayne operating as Batman in a
timeframe set shortly after R.I.P. even
though R.I.P.'s climax as well as R.I.P. crossovers showed Dick Grayson
and others mourning Bruce Wayne's seeming demise. Much later, a couple of extra
Morrison issues showed us that Bruce simply swam out of the river and returned
to the Batcave, making the climactic helicopter crash a mere inconvenience.
Morrison and his editors tried to have their cake and eat it too, with big
reveals that only seemed big at the time. This also played out with Simon
Hurt's last stand as the Devil – or something that might as well be the
Devil – but then getting a later backstory that made him something far less.
And yet again, with Bruce Wayne "dying" in his confrontation with
Darkseid, and the shock of Superman holding Batman's shriveled corpse proving
to be, eventually, not at all what it seemed to be. To experience Morrison's
run in the best way, those endings – the helicopter crash, Doctor Hurt's ambiguous
reveal as the Devil, Superman holding the corpse – have to be endings for the reader, ones that last for a while before the
plot reverses them in a do-over. For a new reader going through the story now,
able to transition immediately from one ending to the next beginning, those
retractions will seem weird or weak. And that's assuming that the reader is
able to read the stories in the original print order, which scrambled the
publication order with the logical and chronological order of the story,
epitomized by Batman and Robin being
published concurrently with Return of
Bruce Wayne and dropping clues in a carefully-planned order even though
their literal timelines were centuries apart. Simply put, it's almost
impossible for any reader who picks up the trades to get the original
experience, and that's a shame because the original experience was so fine.
This is another way in which the expansion of the run from
15 issues as planned to its eventual 75 came at a cost. If there was a
carefully cultivated aspect of the first part of Morrison's work, beginning
with the Joker killing "Batman" in front of disabled children and
ending with the helicopter crash at the end of R.I.P., it was mystery – often achieved through ambiguity. In that
first scene, with a fake Batman dying and shooting the Joker as his life fades,
we were told that we couldn't believe our eyes, and that Morrison was going to
feed us unreliable narration because, with the Joker speaking Morrison's
thoughts, "I love messing with your head." Ambiguity and mystery
remained at the forefront when we saw a pair of black-gloved hands holding the
binoculars that watched Bruce kiss Jezebel, when Damian fought the Devil's
servant in the (a? the?) future, when Bat-Mite seemed maybe to be real with a
creepy insect-like alien behind him, and maybe to be imaginary, when Bruce
spent a day with Honor Jackson, who turned out to have been imaginary or a
ghost. We never got a clarification as to the reality of those things, with
Bat-Mite humorously telling us, "Imagination is the 5th dimension" when he was asked point-blank for
"one straight answer." But this made it clear that lingering,
unresolved mystery was precisely Morrison's objective, with Doctor Hurt turning
out to be "the hole in things, the piece that can never fit" who was
simultaneously several things at once – possibly Bruce's father, possibly the
Devil, and possibly neither of those. Morrison wanted us to know that R.I.P. was the story of how Batman
cheats the Devil, but he also wanted us to know that we didn't truly know anything as a definite fact. This
was what Bat-Mite's non-answer told us quite clearly about Morrison's story
while it told us nothing about the facts. If Morrison's run had ended with
Doctor Hurt on the helicopter, the mystery would have lingered at its fullest,
and that was his original plan. The price of the run being tripled to
quintupled in length is that the ending became a transition and not an ending
at all, and the mystery became much less of a mystery with eventual
expositional reveals, such as Simon Hurt being a pawn of Darkseid and the
"bad" Batman who attacked Dick Grayson being a clone, being necessary
to the plot but also a bit ugly as they defused Morrison's original objective
of mystery.
What we got in exchange for the loss of mystery was, yes,
more good storytelling, but also a deeper examination of the fictional ideal
man, Bruce Wayne. Some of Morrison's finest work was when backstory was told
with murky memories, such as the revenge on Joe Chill that Bruce imagined while
experiencing cardiac arrest, and the synopsis of everything when Bruce was
fighting death after expunging the Hyper-Adapter from his body. And what Morrison
told us, in deeply and frankly psychoanalytical scenes, was that Batman was a
man who lost his family and found life in his friends. He had a symbolic
"bad father" in Simon Hurt, a bad wife (or co-parent) in Talia, two
lost parents and a lost son – no family of any kind to count on. But he
recompensed by finding four virtual sons, and the major climaxes in Morrison's
run ended with each of the Robins saving Bruce's life once – Dick Grayson
in R.I.P., Tim Drake in ROBW, Damian at the mid-point of Inc., and Jason Todd at the very end of
the swordfight with Talia. And after Morrison admitted that it wouldn't make
sense for the Justice League to fly in and save Bruce at the end of R.I.P., he ended ROBW in exactly that way, with Superman, Wonder Woman, and Green
Lantern beating the Hyper-Adapter in a fistfight, and it felt right. Rather
than being a cheap deus ex machina,
Bruce Wayne having powerful friends upon whom he can rely was something
touching and quite natural. Of course the ultimate man is going to have the
ultimate friends, just as he is going to have imitators (the Club of Heroes)
and need to summon greater resources around him (Batman, Inc.). Morrison
doesn't skimp on giving Batman unparalleled stature in the DC Universe. After
cheating the Devil, Batman gets out of bed to escape from Darkseid's death trap
and wounds the dark god. Ultimately (in more senses than one), Batman goes to
the end of time and becomes the central figure in the universe's final moments.
The central riddle in Morrison's Batman #700 was, "What can you beat but never defeat?"
and the double answer was "Time and the Batman." The ten years that
have passed since Morrison's run began passed quickly for me – your
mileage may vary. DC has, remarkably, begun its world anew not once but twice since then with the monthly Batman title having restarted at #1
twice in the 2010s after having only one start in the seven decades before that.
In the calendar of comic cosmology, I often think of the transition from the
last JSA story to the first Barry Allen story as the time between epochs, but
that was only five and a half years, and now since Morrison's long,
contradictory, wonderful story began, we've had ten. The world has moved on and
seems to be doing so at an accelerating pace. The Batman cinematic franchise
that began the year before Morrison's run is also long in the past, with
another actor having played the character twice while another actor plays him
on TV. Batman's history is long and sprawling. These are the words with which
Morrison ended his run: "Batman always comes back, bigger and better,
shiny and new. Batman never dies. It never ends. It probably never will."
There will always be a new Batman for readers and viewers to enjoy. It's
possible that there was never a better time to be reading Batman than during
Morrison's run.
